Stromboli vs. Calzone: What’s the Difference?
Stromboli vs. Calzone: What’s the Difference?
If you’ve ever wondered about the difference between a stromboli and a calzone, you’re not alone. Both dishes involve a delicious filling of cheese, sauce, and toppings encased in dough, and both are typically baked to golden, gooey perfection.
However, these Italian-inspired classics have a few key distinctions that set them apart, from their shapes and cooking methods to the regions they originated from and even the flavors they offer.
When you’re deciding what to order on a menu or looking to make one of these cheesy delights at home, here’s everything you need to know about stromboli vs. calzone.
Origins: Italy vs. Italian-American
One of the main differences between a stromboli and a calzone lies in their origins.
- Calzone: The calzone originates in Naples, Italy. It’s a classic Italian creation that developed as a portable way to enjoy pizza flavors on the go. The word “calzone” means “pant leg” or “trouser leg” in Italian, reflecting its design as a hand-held, folded pastry you can easily eat while walking around the city.
- Stromboli: Unlike the calzone, stromboli has its roots in Italian-American cuisine. Stromboli was first created in the United States in the 1950s, likely in Philadelphia or its surrounding areas. It’s often associated with Italian-American delis and pizza joints. Some believe it was named after the Italian island Stromboli or the 1950 film of the same name, which starred Ingrid Bergman. Either way, stromboli is a distinctly American twist on Italian flavors.
Shape and Construction: Folded vs. Rolled
While both strombolis and calzones are baked with a filling inside the dough, their shapes and construction are quite different.
- Calzone: A calzone is typically a circular piece of dough folded over to form a half-moon shape, similar to an empanada or turnover. The edges are crimped to seal in the filling, which usually consists of cheese, sauce, and other toppings like meats or vegetables. Calzones are often smaller than strombolis, which makes them easy to serve in individual portions.
- Stromboli: A stromboli, on the other hand, is made by rolling a rectangular piece of dough around the filling and sealing it to create a long, cylindrical loaf. The dough is rolled from one end to the other, almost like a burrito, so the filling is spread throughout the entire length. This rolling technique results in a spiral-like cross-section when sliced, giving stromboli its unique, layered appearance.
Takeaway: A quick way to tell them apart? Calzones are half-moon shaped and folded, while strombolis are cylindrical and rolled.
Filling and Toppings: Sauce Inside or on the Side?
Another significant difference between strombolis and calzones lies in how the sauce and fillings are used.
- Calzone: In a traditional Italian calzone, sauce is usually served on the side rather than inside the dough. This way, you dip each bite into marinara sauce, allowing you to control the sauce amount and keep the calzone less soggy inside. Classic fillings for calzones include mozzarella and ricotta cheeses, along with cured meats like ham or salami and vegetables.
- Stromboli: In contrast, stromboli usually has sauce spread directly inside the dough with the fillings before being rolled up. This makes stromboli more akin to a filled pizza roll. Mozzarella cheese is common in stromboli due to its low moisture content, which helps prevent sogginess. Other popular fillings include pepperoni, sausage, and various veggies, creating a flavor similar to that of a hearty pizza.
Takeaway: If you love marinara sauce with every bite, you might prefer stromboli. For a lighter touch of sauce, go for a calzone and dip each bite in marinara as you go.
Dough and Texture: Pizza Dough vs. Bread Dough
While both dishes use dough similar to pizza dough, there are subtle differences in texture due to how they’re prepared and baked.
- Calzone: Since a calzone is fully enclosed and baked in a half-moon shape, it usually has a soft, bread-like texture on the inside with a crispy outer crust. The dough used for calzones is often the same as traditional pizza dough, and it bakes up into a chewy, comforting texture.
- Stromboli: Stromboli dough is often a bit thinner and stretched into a rectangular shape for rolling. This results in a slightly different texture once baked—often a bit crispier and more evenly baked throughout the layers. Because strombolis are typically larger and rolled, they’re sometimes cut into slices and served as an appetizer or shared dish.
Takeaway: For a pillowy, chewy texture, go with a calzone. If you prefer something more structured and crispy, stromboli is the way to go.
Size and Serving Style: Individual vs. Sliced
Stromboli and calzones differ in how they’re usually served, with size and portioning also varying.
Calzone: A calzone is often a single-serving dish, making it the perfect choice if you want a personal meal. Its smaller size means you can eat it by hand, and it’s designed to be portable and easy to handle.
Stromboli: Due to its larger, rolled shape, stromboli is usually baked as a long roll and then sliced into pieces. This makes it ideal for serving as a shared appetizer, party food, or a main dish that can be sliced and shared among several people.
Takeaway: If you’re hosting a party or serving a crowd, stromboli is perfect for slicing and sharing. For individual meals, calzones offer a personal pizza-like experience.
Cooking Techniques: Oven-Baked Classics With Different Sealing
While both strombolis and calzones are baked in an oven, they have slight differences in their sealing techniques.
Calzone: The edges of a calzone are crimped or pressed together, creating a solid seal that keeps the filling contained during baking. This technique also allows the dough to rise slightly, giving the calzone a soft interior with a golden, crispy exterior.
Stromboli: Strombolis are typically rolled up and sealed along the edges, often with a few small slits cut into the top of the dough. These slits release steam as the stromboli bakes, which helps maintain a crisp crust and prevents the filling from becoming soggy. Some recipes even brush the exterior with egg wash or butter for an extra golden finish.
Takeaway: Cutting small slits in the dough of a stromboli can enhance its texture and help you achieve that perfect golden-brown color.
Popular Variations and Toppings
Both strombolis and calzones can be customized with endless variations and fillings.
- Calzone: In Italy, a traditional calzone may be filled simply with mozzarella, ricotta, and prosciutto, while in the U.S., it’s common to add more toppings like mushrooms, peppers, or sausage. Vegetarian versions often include ingredients like spinach, mushrooms, and artichokes.
- Stromboli: Strombolis tend to have a more consistent pizza-like filling profile, with pepperoni, sausage, onions, and bell peppers being popular additions. Some variations include different meats, cheeses, and even creative options like barbecue chicken or buffalo chicken. Takeaway: Whether you’re making a calzone or stromboli, opt for lower-moisture ingredients to prevent sogginess and maintain that perfect, gooey filling.
Takeaway: Whether you’re making a calzone or stromboli, opt for lower-moisture ingredients to prevent sogginess and maintain that perfect, gooey filling.
When To Choose Stromboli vs. Calzone
The choice between a stromboli and a calzone comes down to personal preference and occasion.
- When to Choose Calzone: If you’re in the mood for a handheld, personal pizza experience that’s more bread-like, a calzone is a fantastic option. It’s also ideal if you want to control the sauce by dipping instead of mixing it directly into the filling.
- When to Choose Stromboli: If you’re looking to feed a group or enjoy a shareable dish with pizza-inspired flavors, stromboli is a great pick. Its rolled structure makes it perfect for slicing into individual portions, and it’s a go-to for gatherings and family dinners.
Takeaway: You don’t have to pick just one — make a calzone one night and a stromboli later in the week to fully explore Italian-inspired flavors.